{E-MERGING PROJECT}

Re-enlivening an extinct analog photographic technique

What is a Stereograph?

nypl.digitalcollections.510d47e1-4c3f-a3d9-e040-e00a18064a99.001.w.jpg
The Miriam and Ira D. Wallach Division of Art, Prints and Photographs: Photography Collection, The New York Public Library.(1875).Black Dutchman. Retrieved from http://digitalcollections.nypl.org/items/510d47e1-4c3f-a3d9-e040-e00a18064a99

The Miriam and Ira D. Wallach Division of Art, Prints and Photographs: Photography Collection, The New York Public Library.(1875).Black Dutchman. Retrieved from http://digitalcollections.nypl.org/items/510d47e1-4c3f-a3d9-e040-e00a18064a99

A Stereograph is a pair of photographic images on a single support that, when viewed through a special pair of lenses named, stereoscope, gives the appearance of a single image as having depth and solidity - a three dimensional effect. The standard format of a stereograph is a pair of photographs mounted next to each other on a piece of stiff card. The photographs are not exactly the same, even though both images are taken at the same time. The camera simulates the separation between the eyes and generates images with a slight lateral shift. The distance between the two lenses is 2 1/2 inches (6.3 cm) exactly as the distance between the centers of two human eyes.

The photographs are usually albumen prints and are glued against a colorful paper and around the margins the card bears the name of the photographer’s and/or publisher’s name(s) and a title. The same information is often also included on the back portion of the card.

 
egg.jpg

An albumen print was made by floating a sheet of thin paper on a bath of egg whites containing salt, which have been whisked, allowed to subside, and filtered. This produced a smooth surface, the pores of the paper having been filled by the albumen. After drying, the albumanized paper was sensitized by floating it on a bath of silver nitrate solution or by brushing it on the same solution. The paper was again dried, but this time in the dark.

Sir David Brewster, inventor of the stereoscope.image citation: The Miriam and Ira D. Wallach Division of Art, Prints and Photographs: Print Collection, The New York Public Library. Sir David Brewster, LL.D., K.H., inventor of the stereoscope. Retri…

Sir David Brewster, inventor of the stereoscope.

image citation: The Miriam and Ira D. Wallach Division of Art, Prints and Photographs: Print Collection, The New York Public Library. Sir David Brewster, LL.D., K.H., inventor of the stereoscope. Retrieved from http://digitalcollections.nypl.org/items/510d47dd-ca1e-a3d9-e040-e00a18064a99

Who invented stereoscopic photography? 

In 1838, a year before the invention of photography, British physicist, Sir Charles Wheatstone, was conducting experiments with stereoscopic vision: the slightly different images created by two eyes when looking at an object. That same year he invented a rudimentary stereoscope.

In 1842, the first attempt to create a stereoscopic photograph was made by French-born British daguerreotypist Antoine Francois Claudet. But it would take almost a decade for Scottish physicist, Sir David Brewster, to overcome the limitations of the previews models.  In 1849, the stereograph became a commercial reality by utilizing the reproductability of collodion wet plate process instead of glass plates and daguerreotypes.

America’s Past-time

0025.jpg

Introduced commercially in the United States in 1854, for the next half a century it became a way of life in popular culture. From 1850’s to 1930’s stereoscopic photography became a sensation. not unlike movies, radio and television that would follow it, stereoscopic photographs became a favorite past time.

A vast market was created with numerous photographers and eventually publishing houses exclusively dedicated to stereoscopic views. Many were created with the tourist market in mind and were sold in bookshops, stations and hotels. But these publishing houses had copious catalogs with various themes: from topographic views, the main field in which stereoscope was used,  and images of exotic lands and peoples, including nudes.

The popularity of stereoscopes is revealed when looking at statistics as the ones presented in the book: “Stereo Views - A history of stereographs in America and their collection”. Between 1858 and 1920 it is estimated that four million different stereographs were produced in America. In the year 1862 alone, two publishing houses in Europe produced almost two million stereoscopic views.  The distribution of these views was assured by broad exchange agreements between photographers across nations.

Believe it or not, photographic postcards adopted as a standard size by the postal service in 1907, became the main competitor of stereographs. 677,777,798 postcards were mailed through the U.S. Postal Service from July 1st, 1907 to June 30th, 1908, Becoming the greatest collectible hobby that the world had ever known. Access to the exotic and remote was at one time accessed through stereographs, but now there was also moving pictures and radio for entertainment. By the 1930’s, publishers and photographers saw stereocards as no longer a viable a commercial enterprise.

Find me a stereoscopic photographer !

It is estimated that between 1859 and 1889, there were 6,000 known American Stereographers out of 15,000 active photographers across the country.

Only seven local individuals were actively producing stereographic images in New Jersey in the Monmouth County region. This project will focus on two these photographers: Colwell Lane and David N. Carvalho who establish the New Jersey Stereoscopic View Company between 1872 and 1876.  

 
0028.jpg
0029.jpg

New Jersey Stereoscopic Views Co. Headquaters

 
 
0030.jpg
 

The New Jersey Stereoscopic Views Co.

Between 1872 and 1876, New Jersey Stereoscopic Views Company was formed by photographers Colwell Lane and David N. Carvalho. It is estimated that during the brief four years of existence, New Jersey Stereoscopic Views Co. produced about 200 local views which only about a dozen have been located during a detailed survey of Monmouth County Stereoscopic views published in 1971 by George H. Moss Jr.. This makes it even more relevant to highlight the holdings at New York Public Library Digital Collection attributed to this New Jersey company. 

 
David N. Carvalho circa 1864.

David N. Carvalho circa 1864.

Born in 1848, David N. Carvalho he most likely learned this trade from his father with whom he shared interest in the study of light and in photography. Solomon N. Carvalho was an artist and daguerreotypist who owned a “Portrait, Porcelain, Miniature and Photographic Gallery” located at 765 Broadway in New York City. Solomon N. Carvalho is the first known jewish photographer. According to a catalog created by “The Jewish Historical Society of Maryland in the occasion of a 1989 exhibition dedicated to Carvalho’s artistic endeavors: “only in the United States could the first Jewish photographer have emerged, for only there existed the combination of relative tolerance of Jews, particularly enlightened cities (Charleston and Philadelphia) where Jews could receive exposure to and some training in the Fine Arts, and an intellectual atmosphere which encouraged very broad participation in the scientific discoveries of the day.”

Solomon focused his efforts in earning a living and reputation as a painter and didn’t develop a successful career as a commercial photographer: “Despite his fame as a field photographer, he never embarked on any similar ventures for the purpose of making scenic photographs for sale. He neglected entirely the stereograph, the most popular format for the mass distribution of scenic photographs in the late 1850’s and 1860’s. (...) His photographic efforts at this period were to, perhaps (...) teach his son David the fundamentals of the technique”.

David N. Carvalho would exercised similar creative freedom as his father using exactly the technique his father rejected: in 1872, he became a manager at the New Jersey Stereoscopic Company. In this role David might’ve photographed some of the stereo views but most of his time was most likely spent supervising the production and distribution of the stereoscopic cards. All evidence points to his partner, Colwell Lane, as being the primary photographer. 

Colwell Lane’s carte-de-visite from 1968.

Colwell Lane’s carte-de-visite from 1968.

The carefully composed images created by Lane resulted in stereoscopes of superior quality than his competitors: “few reached the technical excellence evidenced in Lane’s efforts. It should be understood that the mere use of a stereoscopic camera is no guarantee pictures will contain good three-dimensional qualities.” 

Colwell Lane was a skilled photographer who began his career in photography by opening his own studio circa 1866 where he was a prolific producer of Cartes-de-Visite and quality ferrotypes. He deserved the self-title of “photographic artist” which he included in his Cartes-de-Visite. Over twenty three variations of these business cards were found indicating that Colwell Lane had a prolific photographic career. 

By 1876, the partnership of Lane and Carvalho dissolved. Eventually both photographers established their own separate photography enterprises in New York City. Colwell Lane operated his studio in Manhattan from 1888 to 1890.

After closing New Jersey Stereoscopic Views Co., David N. Carvalho sustained  various temporary studio locations, following the trend of photography in uptown Manhattan. In 1877, he opened his first studio which was located at the Carvalho’s household; the following studios remained quite near his father’s residence. David named his business “Carvalho”, probably an indication of lack of business independence from his father who most likely ambled over from time to time to give his son paternal advice. David produced Cartas-de-Visite and cabinet cards with some degree of success and sustained a commercial photography career for the next 10 years. Eventually he became an expert in the study of handwriting and inks, to which studies he was dedicated for the rest of his life.

Who needs a Stereoscope if you have Google Cardboard?

 
cardboard1.jpg

Stereographs originally had to be paired with a stereoscope in order to generate the three dimension effect intended. But you can replicate the “lifelike effect” Sir David Brewster envisioned by viewing original stereoscopic images on a cellphone device and pairing it with google cardboard. Not surprising since, the stereoscope is the grandfather of VR goggles of today.

Both techniques rely on the same principle of physics: “the two eyes see slightly different images when directed at a given object”. Our stereoscopic vision merge the parallel images into one and create the 3D effect originally intended.

All you need to experience the 3D effect is to grab a cellphone device and pair it with a google cardboard viewer.

to build your own viewer all you need are a few everyday items you can find in your garage, online, or at your local hardware store: cardboard, lenses, magnets, hook and loop fastener and a rubber band.


Thanks to Google, who made cardboard viewer open source content in November 2019, you can now download easy DIY instructions.


cardboard2.jpg

how to look at stereographs. Yes, there is a trick.

Would you like to try? I arranged Six images from the Stereoscopic View Collection from the New York Public Library Digital Collection and sequenced into a quick video so you can experience the 3D effect the photographers at the New Jersey Stereoscopic Views Company created over a century ago. 

Just open this video on your cellphone device and position it inside google cardboard as instructed. Start playing the video, and make sure you are displaying it in full screen. 

Look straight at the screen and slowly move the viewer towards you or away from you, until the pair of photographs on the screen blend into one three-dimensional picture. The goal is to merge the two images you see on the screen. Keep cellphone and google cardboard parallel without tipping at an angle. Relax your eyes and do not force yourself to focus. Now, just enjoy the view. 

 

At a time when live-streaming is so common, I hope the quietness of this sequence of images will bring you back to a time when sound and images were not yet merged.

 
285e12906c009bca6807a4297784fd6a.jpg

I’m honestly left with the impression that I didn’t pick these images but, that these images picked me.

One cannot ignore the prevalence of African Americans depicted in the six images selected for this project. It made me realize the context in which stereoscopic photography was invented. The imperialist period coincided with invention of photography and its early techniques. As online collections are being created, thanks to large digitization efforts within cultural institutions the responsibility to present such content within a context of place in time, becomes mandatory to prevent that which started as a preservation of stories into a perpetration of histories.

Although I didn’t have a chance to address this subject here, my interest in the social historical event of photography and the position of stereoscopic images has been ignited to the point that a paper has been written about this topic. (download PDF)

What else can you do with digitized Stereographic collections?

In the 1990’s the relevancy of The Robert N. Dennis Collection of Stereoscopic Views collection was confirmed when NYPL digitized 12,000 stereographic views and present it as the first large-scale digital image collection made available to the public on the internet. 

In addition, NYPL made an incredible effort to bring three-dimensionality back into its Stereoscopic collection.  Since 2012, NYPL’s website allows visitors to experience the stereoscopic views not only as static photographs but through the project Stereogranimator, users can generate animated GIF files from stereoscopic collections from across the country. The flickering images in GIF format attempt to emulate the original 3D effect of the stereoscope technology. This is an an engaging and generous public domain element offered by NYPL given users the ability to share their creations on social media platforms.

But I still enjoy the authenticity sustained by looking at static images through a viewer. I believe, Google Cardboard gives a closer experience to what using an original stereoscope felt like.

 
Replication of stereoscope effect using GIF files. Steregoranmator was created by Joshua Heineman in collaboration with NYPL.

Replication of stereoscope effect using GIF files. Steregoranmator was created by Joshua Heineman in collaboration with NYPL.


Technologies that allowed you to experience these steoreoscopic images:

1440 - Printing Press / Johannesburg Gutenberg 

1445 - Etching / Daniel Hopfer

1502 - Camera Obscura described by Leonardo Da Vinci 

1796 - Lithography / Allis Senefelder 

1806 - Camera Lucida /William Hyde Wollaston

1826 or 1827 - Heliography / Niepce

1834 - Photogenic Drawing / Fox Talbot

June 1838 - Stereoscopic vision / Wheatstone

August 19th, 1839 - Photography / Daguerre

1849 = Illustrated Postcard / Theodore Hook

1841 - Callotype / Fox Talbot

1842 - Cianotype

1843 - Science document using photography / Anna Atkins

1844 - First Photography book / Fox Talbot

1849 - Stereoscope / Brewster

1844 - Telegraph message / Samuel Morse

1850 - Albumen / Louis-Desire Blanquart-Evrard

1850 - Wet Colodium / Frederick Scott Archer

1851 - New York Times first publication

1852 - Ambrotype / James Ambrose Cutting

1853 - First Photo-Journalist / Carol Szathmari

1854 - Carta de Visite / A.A. Disderi

1856 - Colotype / Alphonse Poitevin 

1858 - Photo etching/ Fox Talbot 

1859 - The American Stereoscope / Oliver Wendell Homes

1871 - Gelatin Silver Print /Peter Mawdsley

1873 - Platinum Print / William Willis

1874 - Color Colotype / Joseph Albert 

1876 - Long-distance phone call /Alexander Graham Bell

1878 Consecutive Series of photos / Eadweard Muybridge 

1877 - Phonograph / Thomas Edison

1882 - Gelatin Silver Chloride Prints

1888 - Kodak Camera / George Eastman

1880 - Perforated Celluloid Film / George Eastman

1892 - Movie Camera / Thomas Edison

1894 - Motion Picture Film / Lumiere Brothers

1895 - Radio Signal Transmission / Guglielmo Marconi 

1900 - Photographic Postcards

1904 - First newspaper photo illustrated  

1924 - Leica camera / Oskar Barnack

1927 - Television/ Philo Farnsworth

1929 - Rolleiflex Medium Format Twin Reflex 

1935 - Kodachrome

1935 - Photograph sent via telegraph

1936 - First publication of Life Magazine

1937 - Polaroid / Edwin H. Land

1953 - First Color 3D movie / Andre De Toth

1957 - Drum Scanner / Russel A. Kirch  

1959 - Nikon F

1963 - K-7 Tape

1976 - VHS

1977 - Apple II computer / Steve Wozniak

1979 - Walkman

1980 - CD player

1983 - Internet / Tim Berners-Lee

1985 - Commercial VR Goggles / Jaron Lanier

1987 - Photoshop

1989 - Digital Single-Lens-reflex / Steven Sasson

2004 - Facebook

2005 - Youtube

2007 - iPhone

2010 - Instagram

2012 - Kodak filed for bankrupcy

2014 - Google Cardboard

2019 - Google Cardboard relases as open source

 

About this project

This is a homage to the technique of Stereoscopic Photography that was prevalent from 1850’s to 1930’s. Using The Robert N. Dennis Collection of Stereoscopic Views that is part of the Digital Collection at the New York Public Library (NYPL), I am trying to bring attention to this photographic method by focusing on the history of a particular company that produced stereoscopic photographs in the state of New Jersey.

Images were chosen from The Miriam and Ira D. Wallace Division of Art, Prints and Photographs at New York Public Library (NYPL). This division houses the Robert N. Dennis Collection of Stereoscopic Views described as followed: “The Dennis Collection's total size of more than 72,000 stereoscopic views and its international scope make it one of the largest and most diversely representative holdings of its kind in the world.” 

Creating a narrative became mandatory to allow an intimate interaction with NYPL’s Digital Collection and not overwhelm users with its 72.000 items. I wanted to identify a local stereoscopic photography producer in New Jersey and identify images included in NYPL’s Digital Collection.

Usage of the NYPL database PIC - Photographer’s identity catalog “an experimental interface to a collection of biographical data describing photographers, studios, manufacturers, and others involved in the production of photographic images” was of unprecedented value in the identification and selection of one specific photographic company dedicated to stereography in the State of New Jersey.

Inserting a technological element to this project by pairing cellphone technology and google cardboard, I tried to tie past technologies to the future ones interlaced in our digital era. It is my way of acknoledging the discoveries in science that allowed us to create the virtual environments we utilize seamlessly today. 

As I conclude this exploration I realize the small but otherwise relevant impact of highlighting a small section of images belonging to a cultural archive.

~ Jennifer Cabral

Bibliography

Baldwin, G., & Jürgens Martin C. (2009). Looking at photographs: a guide to technical terms. Los Angeles: J. Paul Getty Museum.

Bajac, Q. (2002). The invention of photography. New York: Harry N. Abrams.

Darrah, W. C. (n.d.). Stereo Views, A History of Stereographs in America and Their Collection. (Gettysburg? Pa., C1964).

Edwards, S. (2006). Photography: a very short introduction. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Heil, D. (2017). The art of stereography rediscovering vintage three-dimensional images. Jefferson, NC: McFarland & Company, Inc., Publishers.

NYPL Digital Library Collections. Retrieved from https://digitalcollections.nypl.org/collections/robert-n-dennis-collection-of-stereoscopic-views#/?tab=about&scroll=13

Paolo Parmeggiani. (2016) From grand tour to virtual tour: Italy through the stereoscope in 1900. Visual Studies 31:3, pages 231-247. 

Saretzky, G. D. (2004). Nineteenth-Century New Jersey Photographers. New Jersey History, No.03. Retrieved from https://jerseyhistory.org/fall-winter-2004-no-3/

Thompson, C. (2017, October 1). Stereographs Were the Original Virtual Reality. Retrieved from https://www.smithsonianmag.com/innovation/sterographs-original-virtual-reality-180964771/

Map: PIC - Photographers' Identities Catalog. (n.d.). Retrieved from http://pic.nypl.org/map/?address.AddressTypeID=*&address.CountryID=*&bbox=*&Nationality=*&gender.TermID=*&process.TermID=*&role.TermID=*&format.TermID=*&biography.TermID=*&collection.TermID=2028165&DisplayName=(Stereoscope~4)&Date=*&mode=2#7965